How did the Caribbean people create new cultures and faiths whilst being enslaved?

This article will be showing the ways scholars have overcome the oppressive system of slavery and colonisation to be able to examine the lives of the enslaved and their descendants. I will be showing these various methods which enable me to discuss the importance of Obeah practices in the Caribbean in future posts.

Historians have been overcoming the limitations of colonisation by exploring the ways enslaved individuals played a role in the everyday life and culture of society. Edward Kamau Brathwaite (originally in 1978) argues that people from a British and West African background born in Jamaica contributed to this new society and culture. This culture was different to any previous known culture; neither British nor West African. This introduced, in the academic space, the idea of a British Caribbean culture that was equally shaped by the British and Africans. This is significant because before 1978 (in the academic space) there was no recognition of African people and their descendants having an impact on society or culture. Orlando Patterson argues that slavery and colonial documents had defined the enslaved person as socially dead from all rights and heritage. They were isolated from their ancestors and descendants, however, this does not mean they did not experience social relations amongst themselves. This is key in showing how I see enslaved peoples agency and influence in the Caribbean. Within the confinement of slavery, people had and will form relations and culture to survive the abuse and torture. This relates to the establishment of Obeah in the time of enslavement and colonisation. How a culture and practice can be formed within this era regardless of the horrors people had faced on a daily basis.

However, researchers and myself always have to keep in mind the power dynamics and systems of enslavement regardless of the culture that was created out of this abuse. Walter Johnson highlights important notes about ‘agency’ when applied to enslaved people. Agency, Johnson argues, was influenced by nineteenth century liberalism so we should be mindful when using the term ‘agency’ as enslaved people’s experiences do not fit into this definition of ‘agency’. I believe that a different definition of agency should be applied when researching enslaved people. Agency, in my opinion when applied to enslaved people, is defined as people acting within their restrictions to feel a sense of control, familiarity, and homemaking. An example of these acts under restriction and punishment are, an act of making food a certain way, continuing a faith from home, or a language or phrases spoken in secret. This type of agency cannot be the same within the system of slavery and we have to adapt to be able to see the acts of agency exercised when possible.

Another development in the academic space that creates the full picture of the Caribbean is including Black women into academic history. A key researcher that focused on Caribbean Black women is Barbara Bush in 1990. There was no previous inclusion of Caribbean black women in scholarly discussion. She argues that the perception of black women was shaped by misconceptions and sexualisation. Bush examines black women by expanding the narrow approach usually applied. By making the distinction between work life and private/hidden community life allows for women’s experiences to be seen. This contribution is important in examining the life of enslaved women in a system that attempts to dehumanise and reduce their presence in society. My research will be developing upon the work of Bush by adopting her angle to understand enslaved peoples’ experiences. This helps us to understand and see how culture can be developed under the worst time in history.

My use of archival material in my research is based on viewing archival material as a product of its time which can show glimmers of enslaved people’s lives and experiences. This understanding of archival material is based on the work of Marisa J. Fuentes. She examines urban Caribbean slavery from the perspective and positions of enslaved women in the traditional archive. Fuentes aims to trace the distortions of enslaved women’s lives that exist in the archives. Using only archival sources to show the everyday lives of enslaved women, present the challenges they had faced, and the continuing colonial power that controls women in the archive today. This change of viewing archival material allows researcher to be able view Caribbean culture from within the top-down oppressive system that this culture was created from. Allowing for more understanding and for more perspectives to be more apparent.

By using these methods and perspective shifts Caribbean people were constantly changing and adapting their ways within the confinements of slavery. This presence is evident in various practices, food, and culture still in present culture of the Caribbean. I also believe this is very much relevant to Obeah practices and knowledge of this practice in present day.

A sign post of different Caribbean islands

Reference list:

Brathwaite, Edward Kamau, The development of Creole society in Jamaica 1770-1820 (Kingston: Ian Randle Publishers, 2005) 2nd ed.

Bush, Barbara, Slave women in Caribbean society, 1650-1838 (Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1990).

Fuentes, Marisa J., Dispossessed Lives: Enslaved women, violence, and the Archive (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016).

Johnson, Walter, ‘On agency’, Journal of social history, 27 (2003), 113-124.

Patterson, Orlando, Slavery and social death: A Comparative study (United States of America: Harvard University Press, 1982).

Further reading:

Hartman, Saidiya V., Scenes of subjection: terror, slavery and self-making in 19th century America (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997).

Mintz, Sidney W., ‘Slave life on Caribbean sugar plantations: Some unanswered questions’, in Stephan Palmie (ed.), Slave cultures and the cultures of slavery (Knoxville: The University of Tennessee Press, 1995) 12-22.

Leave a Reply

I’m Asharnai

Welcome to the dedicated area of the internet to Caribbean natural medical history and Caribbean literature. Here, I invite you to join me on a journey of expanding our expertise of Caribbean knowledge and culture. Working outside of Western norms of knowledge and expression.

Let’s connect